Date: Fri, 9 Sep 2005 23:12:16 -0400 (EDT) From: Louis Epstein Subject: WTC Rebuilding #389:Anniversary Approaches Sunday will mark four years since the Towers were destroyed. This past week ground was broken for the new PATH terminal, and the officials,keen as always to foster the illusion of their mistaken plans possessing irresistible momentum,speak of groundbreakings in the next six months for the FT and memorial. http://nydailynews.com/09-07-2005/news/story/343938p-293668c.html (Of course,they had a supposed "groundbreaking" for the FT more than a year ago,before they admitted it was unbuildable...) Bloomberg took the occasion to plead for donations to fund the hideous official memorial,and family groups opposed to it are going ahead with their September 10th demonstration. The cultural conference that has ruffled many feathers continues to generate news: http://nydailynews.com/front/story/342393p-292318c.html AS NOTED...AT 11 AM SEPTEMBER 11TH I'd like to get together with pro-rebuilders at our traditional demonstration site at City Hall Park...wear shirts,pins,whatever...if you have signs, bring them...we won't be doing the table-and-speech thing but I'll bring my petition clipboard...in case I meet willing people who haven't already signed! Once we've gathered we can walk to the WTC site as a group. Tean Twin Towers has extended the deadline for their Yamasaki-clone design competition (which is not the WTCRM's competition despite the confusing name) to October 28.They've added a row of design pictures to their website but haven't made clear if these are contest entries...some are familiar but not all. Ken Gardner's ally Rosaleen Tallon got an Op-Ed column in the Post,which Peter Walukiewicz sent me: ---------- Forwarded message ---------- Date: Thu, 08 Sep 2005 11:49:12 -0400 Subject: Story from NYPOST.COM from Peter Walukiewicz New York Post Online Edition Peter thought you would find this story from NYPOST.COM interesting: BEYOND BLAME By ROSALEEN TALLON OUR country mourns the loss of thousands of lives again. Our hearts are aching for those who never got a chance to say good-bye. Our nation is again grappling with hard questions and seeking answers. What went wrong? My only sibling, Sean, was killed in the terror attacks of 9/11. He was a firefighter and U.S. Marine Corps reservist. In the privacy of my own heart, I have tried to blame only the terrorists, but I know that my government played a role in his death. From Mayor Rudy Giuliani and Fire Commissioner Thomas Von Essen not procuring the proper radios for my brother and his fellow firefighters, to President Bill Clinton ignoring the build-up of al Qaeda, to the FBI dropping the ball with Mohammed Atta, it is obvious that governmental preparedness and protection of its citizens from terror was unacceptable. It is also obvious that governmental prevention of unnecessary loss of life in the face of natural disaster was unacceptable. It was known to government officials that there were weaknesses in the levees for years. Why weren't these weaknesses addressed long before Hurricane Katrina? As my brother would have said, "It's done." The hurricane has passed, the WTC has fallen. But we are left to find answers. We are left to make it better. We are left to rebuild. It is my solemn wish that the rebuilding effort that commences in New Orleans will be honorable and something to be proud of, something that gives comfort to those who lost so much and hope to the nation that grieves with them. Unfortunately, if I look to how we are rebuilding Ground Zero for some indication as to how the New Orleans rebuild will go, I can't feel too positive. I am ashamed of the current rebuilding effort in New York. What are we rebuilding in New York City? The Lower Manhattan Development Corp. has planned an underground memorial and an underground museum to the lost souls and tragedy of 9/11, with no above-ground remembrance of what happened there. There will be no damaged facades to gaze upon and no trace of many other historical 9/11 artifacts as you walk through the pretty park with two water pools. The site will be sanitized of the human tragedy that occurred there. You will have to go under the ground to see the facade ruins and to remember 9/11. Prominence will be given to an International Freedom Center that focuses on all other events of history and thereby minimizes the event that occurred at this site as just another event in history. This embedding of 9/11 within the context of world history as part of man's march toward freedom will further sanitize the area of the tragedy that occurred there. The centerpiece LMDC building, the Freedom Tower, has undergone so many redesigns that it begs the question: Why was it ever accepted in the first place? It is a fearful and poor attempt to replace our Twin Towers with a look-alike of just one. The base of this tower is 20 stories of windowless concrete, reminiscent of the Soviet Union and its walls of concrete. Is that the new image of our freedom -- fortresses and bunkers? Along with the "Freedom Fort," five mediocre 50-story slanted-roof buildings are planned to replace the southern anchors of the city's skyline. How do slanted roofs fit with the area's proud architecture? Who are we, America? How is all of this happening right before our eyes, New York? What are we becoming, and what will we look like to the world? My brother was taken from me, and our skyline was destroyed, by terrorists. Instead of placing an appropriate memorial to this event and its victims using the actual artifacts that tell the story in the light of day, these artifacts are going to be buried under the ground. Instead of rebuilding our Twin Towers safer and stronger, we are building farcical buildings like the Freedom Tower and the International Freedom Center. In another 10 years, when we reap the new World Trade Center that the LMDC has sown, are we yet again going to ask, "What went wrong?" I am already ashamed. Rosaleen Tallon is co-director of wtctowersmemorial.org. ---------- End forwarded message ---------- I regret the portrayal of the official plan's triumph as inevitable by someone working to promote an alternative,even as I differ with some details of that alternative in terms of what I'd prefer.There are no areas in which the official plan is better than the Gardner plan. Whatever our preferred new-Towers plan we must continue to be loud, we must continue to be visible.That we've had four years without success must not dissuade us from opposing a failure that could last for centuries.Our opponents may be in the position of power but their every effort has been a shambles. Will I see you Sunday? -=-=- The World Trade Center towers MUST rise again, at least as tall as before...or terror has triumphed.